How Old is Too Old to Get a Joint Replaced if You Have Arthritis?

arthritis (OA) is the most common form of arthritis. Itdemonstrates that elderly patients with hip or knee
affects approximately 40 million Americans and thatreplacements for severe OA took several weeks to
number is predicted to rise with the change ofrecover but experienced excellent long-term
demographics occurring as the Baby Boomers age.outcomes.
OA is a disease of articular cartilage, the gristle thatThe study was designed as a prospective study to
caps the ends of long bones and is most common inexamine decision making and clinical outcomes for
weight-bearing joints such as the hips, knees, neck,elderly patients. There were 174 patients entered
low back, base of the thumbs, and great toe joints.into the trial and all were over the age of 65 years.
The treatment regimen for this condition has notPatients had either OA of the hip or knee.
changed appreciably for several years. Among theOA symptoms and functional status were assessed
various treatment options areat baseline and at 12 months.
non-steroidal-anti-inflammatory drugs, local measuresPostoperative symptoms and function were
such as ice, joint injections consisting of eitherassessed at 6 weeks, 6 months, and 12 months
glucocorticoids (“cortisone”), and jointafter surgery.
injections of viscosupplements, lubricants that helpOf the patient group, 76% were female, 17% were
ease the pain and which also help with improvednonwhite, 69% had knee OA, and 31% had hip OA.
function.During a 12-month follow-up, 29% had joint
Assistive devices such as canes and walkers may bereplacement surgery.
useful.Of the patients who had surgery, no patients died,
Other treatments such as arthroscopic debridement17% had postoperative complications, and 38% had
have also helped in some instances.postoperative pain lasting longer than 4wks The
For younger patients (between the ages of 30 tomedian time to recovery for independent walking
60), stem cell therapy appears to be growing inwas 12 days. The median time to be able to perform
enthusiasm.household chores was 49 days.
Unfortunately, when the cartilage has completelyAt 12 months, scores assessing ability to perform
worn away, the options become limited. Total jointactivities of daily living improved by 24 points in the
replacement surgery then appears to be one of thepatients who had surgery and 0.5 points in the
few choices remaining.patients who did not have surgery.
While total joint replacement may be an option forImprovements were 19 and 0.3 points in patients
patients under the age of 65, there has been littleolder than 75 years of age.
data regarding what to do for patients who are olderAmong patients who did not have surgery, 45%
and who need joint replacement.reported that surgery was not offered as a potential
Some patients are fearful of complications and manytreatment option.
physicians are reluctant to advise patients to haveThis study demonstrates that total joint replacement
the surgery because of fear of potentially poorsurgery may be a viable option for many older
outcomes.patients and should not be dismissed as an option
A recent study published in July 2008 by Hamel MBjust because of a patient’s age.
et al in the Archives of Internal Medicine