If I Need a Total Hip Replacement, What Are My Options?

The information provided below is meant to educateCeramic-on-Polyethylene
the patient about the options available to hipYour next option is a ceramic ball and polyethylene
replacement candidates. Your orthopedic surgeonliner. Ceramic heads are harder than metal and are
should explain to you which hip replacement is bestthe most scratch resistant implant material. The hard,
for you and why.scratch resistant, ultra-smooth surface can greatly
In a total hip replacement, both the thigh bonereduce the wear rate on the polyethylene bearing.
(femur) and the socket are replaced with implantThe wear rate for this type of implant is less than
materials and prostheses. Specifically, a metal stem isMetal-on-Polyethylene.
inserted into your thighbone. Attached to the neck ofOne disadvantage found in Ceramic-on-Polyethylene
the stem is a hip ball, just over an inch in diameter.are the incidents of fractures, but newer, stronger
The hip ball fits into a liner. Together, the ball and linerceramics have resulted in fewer of these. Overall, the
create the new joint. The liner is inserted into a metalwear rate for Ceramic-on-Polyethylene is 50% less
shell that in turn is anchored to your pelvis. But therethan that of Metal-on-Polyethylene.
are a number of different approaches a surgeon canIn terms of cost, Ceramic-on-Polyethylene is more
take, depending on her analysis of your particularexpensive than Metal-on-Polyethylene, but less than
case.Ceramic-on-Ceramic.
Because of the advances in the last thirty years,Metal Ball and Metal Liner
several different types of implant materials have alsoMetal-on-Metal bearings were approved by the FDA
been found useful in hip replacement procedures.in 1999, offering the potential for greatly reduced
Each material has its own advantages andwear, with less inflammation and less bone loss.
disadvantages, but it is ultimately up to your surgeonOne clear advantage of metal-on-metal implants is
which materials to use. Beyond the different types ofthe variety of femoral head sizes and neck lengths
materials, a surgeon must also decide whether toavailable (modularity). Metal-on-metal components
anchor the hip implant to the bone using cementallow the largest heads throughout the entire range
fixation or something called "bone ingrowth."of implant sizes. Large ball heads provide increased
Fixationrange of motion and greater stability, which can
For bone ingrowth, the surface of the prosthesessignificantly reduce the risk of hip dislocation, a crucial
simulates the bone with a special granular surface intofactor in the long-term success of an implant.
which the bone grows, thereby locking the implantAlthough wear is reduced, the wear products
into place. Cement fixation holds the implant in the(sub-microscopic particulates, soluble metal ions) are
bone by acting as a filler between the bone and thedistributed throughout the body. This has raised
implant. It is made of a substance that is mixed atconcerns about long-term bio-compatibility. At present
the operation and hardens into a durable, long lastingthese are only concerns, for there have been no
polymer.definitive clinical findings that these wear products are
Modularityharmful.
You may also want to consult with your doctorAnatomic Size Metal-on-Metal Ball Heads
about the design of the implant. Modular systemsBecause the human femoral (ball) head is naturally
offer the ability to interface different sizes oflarge, it makes sense to implant a large, anatomic
femoral heads to fit over the stem; angles, sizes, andreplacement. This was not possible in the past
lengths of the implant are made to fit your anatomy.because traditional polyethylene liners made smaller
The advantage of a modular system is that it givesfemoral heads necessary. However, with the
the patient more flexibility.introduction of metal-on-metal implant components,
Choosing Hip Replacement Implant Materialliners may be eliminated, allowing surgeons to use
The main issue that doctors and patients confrontlarge femoral heads. Use of a larger ball head has
when choosing implant material revolves around thebeen shown to increase the range of motion an
wear debris that is released into your body from anyindividual may experience as well as decrease the
of the implant materials. Even the materials with thepossibility of dislocation.
most wear debris (metal ball and polyethylene liners)Ceramic Ball and Ceramic Liner
show up only after many years (10-15). Nevertheless,Ceramic is the hardest implant material used in the
it is important to educate yourself about the variousbody, and has the lowest wear rate of all, to almost
options for hip replacement surgery.immeasurable amounts (1000 times less than
Metal-on-PolyethyleneMetal-on-polyethylene). These implants have been
Because of its durability and performance,used in Europe for more than 30 years, and since
Metal-on-Polyethylene has been the leading artificial2003 in the United States.
hip component material chosen by surgeons sinceConsequently, there is usually no inflammation or
FDA approval 30 years ago. The metal ball is cobaltbone loss, nor systemic distribution of wear products
chrome molybdenum alloy and the liner isin the body. New ceramics offer improved strength
polyethylene.and more versatile sizing options. However, there has
Metal-on-Polyethylene is the most understood andbeen a very few incidents reported of noises from
practiced of all the procedures. Using these materials,such implants.
a surgeon has a range of options to obtain stability inHip-Resurfacing Option
the body while the operation is underway. This abilityFor younger patients, a total hip replacement may
to adapt and customize during the surgical procedurenot be the best solution for their hip pain because it
is an important attribute of polyethylene. It is also thecan mean difficult and numerous revisions later in life.
least expensive bearing.Hip resurfacing, however, leaves more of the bone in
The disadvantage of Metal-on-Polyethylene isplace, giving these patients more time before a total
shedding over time. After 10 to 15 years, patientship replacement becomes necessary.
who are extremely active may shed debris thatConclusion
results in joint inflammation and bone loss. However,If you are a candidate for hip replacement surgery,
new wear resistant polyethylene liners have beenfixation, modularity, and implant materials are all topics
introduced, called "highly crosslinked polyethylene." Ifthat factor into making the right decision. Your doctor
you are a very active individual or a relatively youngshould explain to you which procedure and materials
patient, your surgeon may prescribe an all-ceramic hipare best for you.
joint or all-metal hip joint.